3 Reasons to Buy a Condo – and 3 Reasons to Beware

Before you commit to owning a home, consider factors like maintenance fees and proximity to neighbors.

U.S. News & World Report

Should You Buy a Condo?

Image of the front porches on a row of condominiums in historic downtown Durango, Colorado.  Behind the homes, the cliff of Smelter mountain can be seem.  The many repeating identical homes are typical row homes.

While a condo can be cheaper than buying a house, you must also factor in the HOA dues.(Getty Images)

If you’re contemplating buying a house, especially in an urban area, you may be asking yourself: Is buying a condo a better deal?

What Is a Condo?

A condominium, which is like a hybrid between an apartment and a house, is property that you can purchase and own outright. A condo offers some similar aspects of apartment living. For instance, many condos are adjacent to others, so owners often share a wall. And if you live in a high-rise building, your condo may be located above or below someone else's home.

If you talk to friends or family members who live in condominiums, you'll quickly find out that many people love the condo life, while some people wish they bought a house instead.

Toying with the idea of committing to a condo? Here are top benefits – and some drawbacks – to factor into the decision-making process.

Pro: You Won't Have a Yard to Mow

This is a big appeal of owning a condo. There will be no mowing because you'll pay dues to a condominium association, which will take care of most of your maintenance needs.

"I have not lifted a snow shovel or mowed a lawn in 12 years. It's been marvelous," says John Goodman, who owns the public relations firm John Goodman PR. He and his wife owned a house in Scarsdale, New York, before moving to the village of Tuckahoe, New York. As for their condo, he says, "It was one of the best life decisions we've ever made."

Con: Having the Outdoor Workload Managed Isn't Always Easy

Some condominiums are underfunded and don't have the money to pay for regular maintenance. It's important to ask a lot of questions and make sure the association is well-run before buying a condo, and find out how many condos the association manages. If a dozen members struggle with paying dues in any given month and your community has 500 condos, you aren't likely to feel the impact. However, if you live in a community of 10 condos and two people fall behind, there goes 20 percent of the association's budget.

Pro: It's Cheaper Than Buying a Comparable House

The cost of a condo versus a house depends on the size of the home, the property values of the neighborhood and the cost of living in the area. Typically, you'll spend less on a condo, industry experts say, and historically, single-family detached homes have appreciated faster than condominiums.

However, while houses have appreciated faster than condominiums for years, condos aren't doing poorly. According to data from real estate information company Zillow, the typical condo market value climbed nearly 42% between May 2010 and May 2020.

Con: The Price of the Condo Isn't All You'll Have to Account For

You don't just have to think about appreciation and mortgage payments. Remember to factor in association dues. You could shell out anywhere from $100 a month to more than $1,000, depending on the location and whether you're looking at a luxury or no-frills condominium community. Still, these dues are often going to amenities, such as 24-hour gated security or a first-class gym or pool.

Jonathan Little, a professional poker player who runs the website JonathanLittlePoker.com, says that he owns two condos that he rents out. "I initially assumed a condo must be a good idea for someone who did not want to take care of maintaining a house," Little says. "However, I quickly realized that the $250 a month that my condo board charged me for the pleasure of being under their management was drastically overpriced. Sure, they cut the grass and kept the outside of the condo looking nice, but they were not responsible for anything inside the condo."

And plenty can go wrong inside a home, such as plumbing issues or your air-conditioning and heating unit could go out, for instance.

You could also find yourself on the receiving end of an assessment. What's that, you say? Every month, a portion of your condo fees goes into the development's reserves. That's where the condo association gets the money to fund occasional projects, such as repainting the building's exterior. If an expense can't be delayed – let's say a pipe burst and there isn't enough in the reserve to cover repairs – condo owners could be asked to pay an assessment, which can range from a minor pittance to thousands of dollars. These unexpected financial hits aren't pleasant, but unplanned expenses occur frequently with houses as well.

Also keep in mind that condos can be harder to sell than houses. You can brag to homebuyers about your spacious bedrooms or all the amenities in your condo building, but if many of your neighbors are also selling at the same time, there may not be much to distinguish your condo from theirs.

Pro: There Is a Sense of Community

Plenty of people who own houses would say the same thing about their own neighborhood, but remember that condo owners tend to live much closer to each other than many suburban homeowners, who often have relatively big yards separating them.

Mark Scott, a New York City-based corporate communications executive for eVestment.com, a website aimed at the investment community, says that he became a more social person living in a condo.

"Like most Americans, once you drive into that garage, you don't come back out until the next day. Living in a condo you see your neighbors in the elevator or at the pool or in the lounge and lobby," Scott says. "You're also more likely to go back out because many condos are in areas where interesting bars, restaurants, parks and so on are within an easy walk. So I found myself much more active and met many more of my neighbors and did things with them more often than I ever did living in a house."

Con: You Can't Pick Your Neighbors

Scott likes the social, community-driven aspect of living in a condo, but there are downsides, too.

"As much as I enjoy the interaction with neighbors I get in a condo, you're not going to get along with or like everyone, so the downside is that you're still going to run into those people," he says. "In my Atlanta condo, there was a woman with two dachshunds that were very badly behaved – barking at other dogs in the elevator. Whenever I was taking my dogs out, if she was in the elevator I would have to wait for the next one. So I really didn't like that."

Scott says that he has heard of friends who moved into buildings on the recommendations of others – and then had fights with those friends, making living in the same building uncomfortable. "That never happened to me, but it's certainly a possibility in communal living like that," he says.

The grass is rarely greener on the other side of the fence. But at least on one side of the fence, you'll never have to mow the lawn.

Updated on June 26, 2020: This story was published at an earlier date and has been updated with new information.

Wealth of Knowledge Podcast

Wealth of Knowledge is a weekly podcast featuring tips and expert insight on all things money: personal finance, careers, investing, real estate and more.

Wealth of Knowledge logo