6 Home Renovations You Think Will Pay Off – But Won't

Expecting to recoup your money on that patio or master bedroom addition? Don't count on it.

By Teresa Mears, Contributor |March 16, 2017, at 4:08 p.m.

6 Home Renovations You Think Will Pay Off – But Won't

Slideshow

Don't expect a big return on most home improvement investments.

Carpenter Square

(Getty Images)

When setting out to improve your home, you’re usually motivated by making the space more comfortable for your family. You justify the expense by saying that the project will inevitably add value to your home. But most home improvements don't add as much value to your home as you spend on the project, at least if you’re going to sell soon. Remodeling magazine’s 2017 Cost vs. Value report, which analyzed 29 projects in 99 U.S. markets, found the only improvement that added more value than it cost, using a national average, was adding insulation to the attic. Smaller, less expensive projects like adding a new steel door tended to bring a better rate of return than large, high-priced projects like a master suite addition.

ROI varies by project and location.

ROI varies by project and location.

Residential street in New York suburb, New York, United States of America.

(Getty Images)

Exactly which renovations will add value depends on where you live – not just your city or region but your neighborhood. Installing a feature that people in your neighborhood expect (and need) is more likely to pay off than adding high-end features not found in most other homes. And adding square footage to a small home in a neighborhood of larger homes is more likely to pay dividends than making your home the largest in the neighborhood. The Cost vs. Value report also estimates costs on the high end, so in some cases a more modest version of projects may yield as much or more value than going all out.

Adding an in-ground pool.

Adding an in-ground pool.

Los Angeles home, exterior

(Getty Images)

The average cost for homeowners to add a pool was $41,975, according to reports by HomeAdvisor.com customers. In most markets, you’re unlikely to be adding nearly that much to your home’s value. While a pool is more likely to be prized in an area where the weather is warm and most nearby homes have pools, even in those neighborhoods it typically doesn't boost the value anywhere near what it cost to install it. The Cost vs. Value report does not include pools.

Gourmet kitchen renovation

Gourmet kitchen renovation

Kitchen in New Luxury Home with Open Floorplan

(Getty Images)

Redoing your kitchen with high-end finishes and professional appliances might look great, but it won’t yield nearly what you spent when you go to sell. According to the Cost vs. Value report, a major kitchen remodel added 65.3 percent of its $62,158 cost to a midrange home and 61.9 percent of its $122,991 cost to an upscale home. A minor kitchen remodeling project – replacing some appliances, laminate countertops and cabinet doors – had a much better return on investment, returning 80.2 percent of its cost in value to a midrange home.

Patio or deck

Patio or deck

Nailing a deck

(Getty Images)

You might think that adding a patio would significantly boost a home’s value. But the Cost vs. Value report calculated that adding a 20-by-20-foot flagstone patio, with new sliding-glass doors, a fire pit, pergola and outdoor kitchen, would return only 54.9 percent of its $51,985 cost for a midrange home. A more modest 16-by-20-foot deck addition fared better, returning 65.2 percent of the $17,249 cost of a composite deck and 71.5 percent of the cost of a $10,707 wood deck, both for a midrange house.

Master suite addition

Master suite addition

luxury lamp and books on bedside table in bedroom

(Getty Images)

In general, it’s hard to get your money back from an addition because the project is so costly. Remodeling magazine estimates the cost of a midrange master bedroom addition at $119,533 and predicts that it will add only $77,506 to the home’s value, or 64.8 percent of its cost. On an upscale home, the project would return 59.9 percent of its $250,687 cost.

Adding a bathroom.

Adding a bathroom.

New bathroom cabinets with granite countertopsBathroom renovation and granite installation

(Getty Images)

Another bathroom would really increase your home's value, right? Well, the Cost vs. Value report found that a bathroom addition added only 64.8 percent of its $43,232 cost to a midrange home and 57.1 percent of its $81,515 cost to an upscale home. Adding a bathroom within your home’s existing footprint, which has a much lower cost, is likely to yield more value versus its cost, especially if you’re adding a second bathroom to a one-bath house.

Installing new windows.

Installing new windows.

A man puts in an energy efficient window.

(Getty Images)

Many homeowners mistakenly believe that installing new windows will cut costs for heating and air conditioning, but it usually takes many years to get back the cost in energy savings. While new windows may improve your home’s look and feel with more natural lighting, they rarely add as much value as they cost. A 2015 survey by the National Association of Realtors estimated that installing new vinyl windows would recoup 80 percent of the $15,000 cost when the home sells, but only installing wood windows would reap 58 percent of the $26,000 cost. Remodeling magazine's Cost vs. Value report estimated that new windows would regain about 70 percent of their cost in an upscale home, whether the windows were wood or vinyl.


Teresa Mears writes about personal finance, real estate and retirement for U.S. News and other publications. She was previously the real estate blogger for MSN Money and worked as the Home & Design editor for The Miami Herald. During her journalism career, she worked on coverage of immigration, religion, national and international news and local news, serving on the staffs of The Miami Herald, The Los Angeles Times and the St. Petersburg Times. She has also been a contributor for The New York Times and The Boston Globe, among other publications. She publishes Living on the Cheap and Miami on the Cheap. Follow her on Twitter @TeresaMears.

Recommended Articles

How to Write an Offer Letter to a Seller

Tania Isacoff Friedland | Sept. 17, 2020

Connect with home sellers to make them feel good about letting you purchase their home.

The Guide to Understanding Home Value

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 15, 2020

Here's a look at the process of calculating the value of your home and what it means for your home's sale price.

What to Know About Moving to Chicago

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 10, 2020

Chicago can be a great place to live if you can handle the cold winter and cost of living and embrace public transit.

How to Set Up Your Utilities

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 9, 2020

Here's what you need to know about which utility company services your new address, how to set up an account and why you may need to pay a deposit.

What to Know About the Halt on Evictions

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 3, 2020

The CDC has announced a halt on evictions through the end of 2020, but certain criteria keep some renters vulnerable to eviction. And the rent is still due.

How to Declutter Your Home

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 3, 2020

Follow this step-by-step guide to make your home more manageable and organized.

Deed vs. Title: What to Know

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 1, 2020

Learn how the deed and title play into homeownership, and the details you need to know before closing on a home.

Is Fee Simple or Leasehold Better?

Devon Thorsby | Sept. 1, 2020

Learn the different ways you can hold property with fee simple ownership or a leasehold.

How to Factor in a Home's Outdoor Space

Tania Isacoff Friedland | Aug. 27, 2020

While outdoor space has always been considered an appealing feature to homebuyers, there's newfound value in having a private outdoor oasis.

Should You Build a Mother-in-Law Suite?

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 25, 2020

These additional living spaces could give you the guest space or rental income you're looking for.

25 Small Space Decor Ideas for Your Home

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 21, 2020

These tips can make a small room feel bigger and help you master organization with minimal storage.

5 Things to Ignore on a Home Tour

Allison Chiaramonte | Aug. 20, 2020

Don't rule out a potential home for the wrong reasons. Focus on the details that count.

Why Tenants Are Not Safe From Eviction

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 19, 2020

People struggling to pay rent should still be worried about eviction should local eviction moratoriums end.

How to Vet a Neighborhood Before Moving

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 17, 2020

Before signing a lease or buying a house, visit frequently, check neighborhood safety and learn more about the area.

What Is a Duplex?

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 11, 2020

Learn the basics about duplex properties, and how they can be a first step for people looking to invest in real estate.

Should You Live in a Single-Family Home?

Steven Gottlieb | Aug. 11, 2020

Depending on your own priorities, finances and bandwidth, one style of living might be better for you.

Denver Housing Market Forecast

Andrew Fortune | Aug. 6, 2020

Here's what you need to know about the Denver housing market now, and what to expect in the future.

How to Make and Accept an Bid on a Home

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 6, 2020

Here's what you need to know to go under contract and move toward a successful home purchase or sale.

Considerations Before Buying a Vacation Home

Geoff Williams | Aug. 5, 2020

You'll want to think about money, rental challenges and market.

How to Build a Fire Pit in Your Backyard

Devon Thorsby | Aug. 4, 2020

Follow these 10 simple steps to transform your backyard into a rustic retreat.